Why Do We Need useLayoutEffect?
July 20, 2020
If you have worked at all with React hooks before then you have used the useEffect
hook extensively. You may not know, though, that there is a second type of useEffect
hook called useLayoutEffect
. In this article I will be explaining the useLayoutEffect
hook and comparing it to useEffect
. If you are not already familiar with useEffect
check out my full article on it here.
The Biggest Difference
Everything about these two hooks is nearly identical. The syntax for them is exactly the same and they are both used to run side effects when things change in a component. The only real difference is when the code inside the hook is actually run.
In useEffect
the code in the hook is run asynchronously after React renders the component. This means the code for this hook can run after the DOM is painted to the screen.
The useLayoutEffect
hook runs synchronously directly after React calculates the DOM changes but before it paints those changes to the screen. This means that useLayoutEffect
code will delay the painting of a component since it runs synchronously before painting, while useEffect
is asynchronous and will not delay the paint.
Why Use useLayoutEffect
?
So if useLayoutEffect
will delay the painting of a component why would we want to use it. The biggest reason for using useLayoutEffect
is when the code being run directly modifies the DOM in a way that is observable to the user.
For example, if I needed to change the background color of a DOM element as a side effect it would be best to use useLayoutEffect
since we are directly modifying the DOM and the changes are observable to the user. If we were to use useEffect
we could run into an issue where the DOM is painted before the useEffect
code is run. This would cause the DOM element to be the wrong color at first and then change to the right color due to the useEffect
code.
You Probably Don’t Need useLayoutEffect
As you can see from the previous example, use cases for useLayoutEffect
are pretty niche. In general it is best to always use useEffect
and only switch to useLayoutEffect
when you actually run into an issue with useEffect
causing flickers in your DOM or incorrect results.
Conclusion
useLayoutEffect
is a very useful hook for specific situations, but in most cases you will be perfectly fine using useEffect
. Also, since useEffect
does not block painting it is the better option to use if it works properly.